web/docs/platform-spec-alignment-review.md

1.9 KiB

Platform Spec Alignment Review

Sources Referenced

  • /Users/vsg/Documents/VSG Codex/kernel/docs/architecture/PRODUCT_ARCHITECTURE.md
  • /Users/vsg/Documents/VSG Codex/kernel/docs/architecture/REPO_TOPOLOGY_25Y.md
  • /Users/vsg/Documents/VSG Codex/platform-docs/business/38_license_model.md (noted as potentially legacy relative to latest direction)

Alignment Summary

The revised web copy is aligned with core platform direction on:

  1. Deterministic governance as primary execution/control model.
  2. Layered architecture where intelligence is optional augmentation.
  3. Local-first durability and operational resilience framing.
  4. Open/closed boundary discipline (no disclosure of private kernel internals).
  5. Wallet-first identity continuity aligned with licensing architecture direction.
  6. Membership-gated commerce model separated from product entitlement rights.

Resolved Conflicts from Initial Web Draft

  1. Ownership/IP overstatement removed.
  • Previous copy implied full source-code transfer in all cases.
  • Revised copy now uses contractual-boundary language.
  1. Crypto exclusion statement removed.
  • Previous copy categorically denied crypto association.
  • Revised copy avoids hard claims that can conflict with evolving licensing rails.
  1. Secret system spec correctness fixed.
  • Mailgun signing verification now references signing key.
  • Failure handling now avoids silent acceptance on processing failure.

Deliberate Neutrality Choices

To avoid drift between evolving licensing specs and public marketing:

  • No fixed pricing is stated.
  • No hard commitment to one entitlement unit (per-human vs per-device) is stated on landing page.
  • No claim is made that requires publishing proprietary module/kernel implementation details.

Recommendation

Treat this web repo as the public narrative layer, and keep constitutional licensing/mechanics claims anchored in dedicated legal and contract documents as those finalize.